
The Case for Microbrands
Imagine this scenario. Two boxers enter a ring. One of them weighs 85 kg, while his opponent weighs all of 60 kg. At the sound of the final bell both are still standing and each has inflicted the same amount of damage on the other. Since a 25-kg weight deficit is a severe handicap in a physical contest of this sort, spectators are forced to conclude that the skinny competitor is the superior boxer.
The underlying theme of this scenario has gripped evolutionary biologists who wrestle with a genetic paradox: natural selection sometimes favours characteristics that encumber their possessors. The male peacock’s tail is a classic example. Not only is it an unnecessary burden; its bright-coloured ostentatiousness forces the peacock to live in a state of permanent exposure. But that is precisely the point, according to some experts. By making it impossible to defer or transfer risk, the tail sends a clear signal that the peacock possesses the qualities necessary for survival. They call this the ‘handicap principle’.
In the horological world, microbrands are instances of the handicap principle: small companies surviving in a landscape dominated by corporate behemoths, courting a public that equates lack of heritage with lack of quality. As with the peacock and our skinny boxer, the continued existence of a microbrand is, in many cases, a signal of competence.
Microbrands are a relatively recent phenomenon. They are limited-production operations, sometimes run by a single individual, that tend to specialise in a particular style of watch. They typically lack the resources to produce components in-house, and meet their needs mostly by outsourcing. They tend to skip the middleman by selling directly to consumers, mainly through their own websites. With low initial capital investment and low marketing and advertising overhead, it’s possible for them to put together a decent watch and retail it for a reasonable price — between $500 and $2,500.
Trouble is, so can their competitors, many of which happen to be century-old enterprises. As we’ve mentioned before[link to blog 12, ‘Steampunk Vibes’], a brand’s backstory is an invaluable resource because watch consumers — especially in the mechanical-watch segment — are highly prone to nostalgia. Established brands can always mine their extensive catalogues and reinterpret, or reimagine, or repackage, historic releases. They can also lean on some episode in their past — a military connection here, a movie-star endorsement there — that provides juicy marketing fodder.
With plenty of marketing and advertising dollars at their disposal, big brands have the ability to saturate the airwaves with their promotional message and simply overwhelm their shallow-pocketed microbrand competitors. Even in the age of independent digital media, algorithmic incentives are such that content creators are reluctant to devote their limited bandwidth to little brands that nobody’s ever heard of.
One might assume that as long as they procure components from third-party manufacturers cost-efficiently, microbrands can corner the value-conscious slice of the market. Except that manufacturing is yet another arena where big companies can throw their weight around. A big-name brand might acquire the same component from the same vendor as a microbrand, but the size of its order lets it secure a lower price per unit than a small-batch manufacturer. In many cases, the component supplier is itself owned by the same conglomerate as the big-name brand. Such relationships not only ensure favourable financial terms; they allow the major players to acquire components that match their exact specifications. This makes their path from concept to final product virtually frictionless. Meanwhile, the microbrand has to settle with the off-the-shelf option it’s given.
In short, life is tough for microbrands. Their relative youth precludes them from cashing in on nostalgia; they have to make do with whatever media crumbs big brands leave on the table; they cannot benefit from economies of scale and they cannot tap into a network of corporate connections, which often means smaller margins than the big-name competition.
And yet, some of them survive. Like our skinny boxer, some of them roll with the punches and make the most of their lean, agile structure. Their margins are small, so they learn to allocate their resources with prudence and forethought. They become adept at identifying market gaps and offering solutions quickly. Knowing that big-name competitors tend to lean conservative, they take chances with unconventional designs. Knowing that compromise in terms of technical spec is often unavoidable, they might pay particular attention to things like finishing or bracelets and straps or dial texture.
However they do it, the mere fact that they stay in business makes them worthy of our attention. Stay tuned to this blog as we spotlight a couple of notable examples in a forthcoming post.